New Comparative Fault Rule Will Bar Some Injury Claims Starting in 2026

Donald D'Aunoy • June 13, 2025
new comparative fault laws in Louisiana

In May 2025, Governor Jeff Landry signed House Bill 431, which amends Louisiana Civil Code Article 2323. The new law transitions Louisiana from a pure comparative fault system in personal injury cases to a modified comparative fault rule with a 51% bar to recovery. That means if you're found to be 51% or more at fault for an accident, you will be barred from recovering any compensation.


The new rule goes into effect on January 1, 2026.


What Happens to Accidents That Happen Before 2026?


If your accident occurs before January 1, 2026, the current pure comparative fault rule still applies. Under that model, you can be 90% at fault and still recover 10% of your damages. The new rule only applies to accidents that happen on or after January 1, 2026.


If your case is still pending when the law changes, or if you had an accident before January 1, 2026, and haven’t filed a claim yet (assuming the statute of limitations hasn’t run out), the old pure comparative fault doctrine will apply to your case.


How Comparative Fault Affects Compensation


Whether you're dealing with the current rule or the new one, fault can directly impact your settlement amount. The basic idea of comparative fault isn’t being changed. There’s just a new threshold of fault that could bar a plaintiff’s recovery.


Let’s say your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and property damage total $100,000. If you're found 25% at fault, your award would be reduced by that percentage, meaning you’d receive $75,000.


Under the current system, even if you were 75% at fault, you could still receive $25,000. But in accidents that happen in 2026 and onwards, if you're found 51% or more at fault, you get nothing.


That one change makes fault disputes much more critical, especially in cases where blame is contested or where there’s limited evidence.


How Will the New Comparative Fault Law Change the Approach of Auto Accident and Personal Injury Lawyers?  


This new law has the potential to impact virtually every facet of personal injury law, from influencing which cases an auto accident lawyer chooses to accept to how they approach investigating, advocacy, and negotiations.


When fault is clear-cut and the other driver is entirely or mostly to blame, not much changes. But in cases where both sides share responsibility, things will become more complicated. People injured in crashes where fault is contested may have a harder time finding lawyers to take their case.


Injured drivers who initially appear to be at fault could simply be out of luck. Even if a more thorough investigation could reveal that they weren’t primarily responsible, many lawyers won’t want to commit time and resources unless there’s a strong initial indication that the client will be eligible for compensation.


That’s why it’s more important than ever to talk to a lawyer early in the process, preferably before you speak to an insurance company or give a recorded statement. Fault can shift based on the smallest detail in your version of events, especially when there’s little evidence and fault is being determined primarily based on the testimony of the people involved in the accident.


At the Law Office of Donald D’Aunoy Jr., LLC, we’ll examine every angle of your case—from witness statements and police reports to traffic laws and physical evidence—before making any recommendations. We don’t shy away from tough cases if we believe we can win or negotiate to a successful conclusion through in-depth investigation and legal legwork.


Talk to Lawyer Don About Your Car Accident in New Orleans


Not sure how this new rule might affect your case? Have questions about how fault is determined? Call Lawyer Don today at (504) 508-6414 or contact us online for a free consultation. We are always prepared to give honest answers to people injured in accidents, even if there are questions about who was at fault.   



By Donald D'Aunoy May 12, 2025
In today’s fast-paced world, the urge to stay connected at all times can lead to dangerous consequences, especially when it comes to texting while driving . This act, seemingly harmless for those who believe they can multitask , has proven to be a significant cause of accidents on the road . As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans , I have seen firsthand the devastating impact that a moment’s distraction can have on lives and families. This blog post aims to shed light on the real dangers of texting while driving and why it’s a risk not worth taking . The Reality of Distracted Driving Texting while driving is a form of distracted driving that has garnered national attention due to its high potential for causing accidents. When drivers take their eyes off the road to send a text, they are not just diverting their visual attention but also their manual and cognitive focus away from driving. This triple threat significantly increases the likelihood of an accident. Studies have shown that texting while driving can delay a driver’s reaction time as much as alcohol consumption. The reality is stark: drivers who text are 23 times more likely to be involved in a crash than those who don’t. The Legal Implications in Louisiana In Louisiana, the law is clear: texting while driving is illegal. This legislation reflects a growing awareness of the dangers associated with mobile phone use behind the wheel. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, I have navigated the complexities of Louisiana’s distracted driving laws to advocate for victims of such negligence. The legal system in our state recognizes the severe risks posed by texting and driving, imposing penalties on those who disregard this law. However, beyond the legal consequences, the real cost of texting while driving can be measured in human lives — the injuries and fatalities that could have been avoided. The Role of a Personal Injury Lawyer When accidents caused by texting while driving occur, the victims often face a long road to recovery. Physical injuries, emotional trauma, and financial burdens are common aftermaths. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, my role is to ensure that victims receive the justice and compensation they deserve. Through meticulous investigation and leveraging Louisiana’s distracted driving laws, I work to hold negligent drivers accountable for their actions. My commitment to my clients goes beyond legal representation; it’s about restoring their peace of mind and helping them rebuild their lives. Conclusion The dangers of texting while driving are clear, and the consequences are too severe to ignore. It’s a societal issue that requires collective action — from stricter enforcement of distracted driving laws to individuals committing to never text and drive. As a community, we must prioritize safety over convenience to prevent needless accidents and loss of life. If you or a loved one has been affected by a distracted driving accident, know that you are not alone. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, I am here to offer the legal support and guidance needed to navigate the aftermath of such incidents. In conclusion, texting while driving is a dangerous practice that puts everyone on the road at risk. The momentary satisfaction of sending a text is never worth the potential for causing harm. Let’s commit to keeping our roads safe by keeping our phones down and our focus on the road ahead. If you find yourself in need of assistance or legal advice following a distracted driving accident , do not hesitate to reach out to a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans who can help protect your rights and interests.
By Donald D'Aunoy April 23, 2025
Festivals in New Orleans are a time of celebration, music, food, and community. From Mardi Gras to French Quarter Fest, the streets come alive with excitement. However, with all the joy and chaos, the risk of car accidents significantly increases. Crowded streets, distracted drivers, and an influx of tourists unfamiliar with local roads can quickly […]
By Donald D'Aunoy April 16, 2025
Every year, the New Orleans Jazz & Heritage Festival draws hundreds of thousands of visitors from across the country, transforming the city into a vibrant cultural hotspot. While this festival brings music, food, and celebration to the forefront, it also unfortunately brings a spike in traffic accidents. The city’s streets become more congested than usual, […]
By Donald D'Aunoy April 9, 2025
Spring in New Orleans is a season filled with vibrant energy, cultural celebrations, and lively festivals. From Mardi Gras to French Quarter Fest and countless neighborhood parades, the city becomes a magnet for locals and tourists alike. While these events bring joy and excitement, they also create an environment where traffic incidents spike dramatically. Understanding […]
By Donald D'Aunoy April 3, 2025
The French Quarter Festival is one of the most anticipated cultural events in New Orleans. Drawing in thousands of locals and tourists alike, it offers an incredible mix of live music, food, and local art. But with large crowds, heavy foot traffic, and busy streets, safety should be a top priority for anyone attending. Whether […]
By Donald D'Aunoy May 12, 2025
In today’s fast-paced world, the urge to stay connected at all times can lead to dangerous consequences, especially when it comes to texting while driving . This act, seemingly harmless for those who believe they can multitask , has proven to be a significant cause of accidents on the road . As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans , I have seen firsthand the devastating impact that a moment’s distraction can have on lives and families. This blog post aims to shed light on the real dangers of texting while driving and why it’s a risk not worth taking . The Reality of Distracted Driving Texting while driving is a form of distracted driving that has garnered national attention due to its high potential for causing accidents. When drivers take their eyes off the road to send a text, they are not just diverting their visual attention but also their manual and cognitive focus away from driving. This triple threat significantly increases the likelihood of an accident. Studies have shown that texting while driving can delay a driver’s reaction time as much as alcohol consumption. The reality is stark: drivers who text are 23 times more likely to be involved in a crash than those who don’t. The Legal Implications in Louisiana In Louisiana, the law is clear: texting while driving is illegal. This legislation reflects a growing awareness of the dangers associated with mobile phone use behind the wheel. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, I have navigated the complexities of Louisiana’s distracted driving laws to advocate for victims of such negligence. The legal system in our state recognizes the severe risks posed by texting and driving, imposing penalties on those who disregard this law. However, beyond the legal consequences, the real cost of texting while driving can be measured in human lives — the injuries and fatalities that could have been avoided. The Role of a Personal Injury Lawyer When accidents caused by texting while driving occur, the victims often face a long road to recovery. Physical injuries, emotional trauma, and financial burdens are common aftermaths. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, my role is to ensure that victims receive the justice and compensation they deserve. Through meticulous investigation and leveraging Louisiana’s distracted driving laws, I work to hold negligent drivers accountable for their actions. My commitment to my clients goes beyond legal representation; it’s about restoring their peace of mind and helping them rebuild their lives. Conclusion The dangers of texting while driving are clear, and the consequences are too severe to ignore. It’s a societal issue that requires collective action — from stricter enforcement of distracted driving laws to individuals committing to never text and drive. As a community, we must prioritize safety over convenience to prevent needless accidents and loss of life. If you or a loved one has been affected by a distracted driving accident, know that you are not alone. As a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans, I am here to offer the legal support and guidance needed to navigate the aftermath of such incidents. In conclusion, texting while driving is a dangerous practice that puts everyone on the road at risk. The momentary satisfaction of sending a text is never worth the potential for causing harm. Let’s commit to keeping our roads safe by keeping our phones down and our focus on the road ahead. If you find yourself in need of assistance or legal advice following a distracted driving accident , do not hesitate to reach out to a personal injury lawyer in New Orleans who can help protect your rights and interests.
By Donald D'Aunoy April 23, 2025
Festivals in New Orleans are a time of celebration, music, food, and community. From Mardi Gras to French Quarter Fest, the streets come alive with excitement. However, with all the joy and chaos, the risk of car accidents significantly increases. Crowded streets, distracted drivers, and an influx of tourists unfamiliar with local roads can quickly […]
More Posts